Loved this one! A magical YA adventure with quirky magic and lovable characters.

Oh my gosh, I was in *the worst* reading slump. I was DNF’ing books left and right and legitimately wondering if there was something wrong with me. But then this book sucked me and was just completely gorgeous. It reminded me of a mash-up of Uprooted, Howl’s Moving Castle, Dr. Who, and Beauty and the Beast, and I just loved (almost) every step of the way!

What I liked:
– Gorgeous writing
– Complex characters I loved
– A beautiful but dangerous magical forest
– A sweet, slowburn romance
– Perfect pacing that kept me engaged from the first page
– Found family that just wraps around you
– A perfect fairy tale vibe that still feels fresh

What I didn’t like:
– The last page. I’m trying really hard to say this without spoiling anything, but basically I wanted more of a happy ending than that hopeful but still vague last line. Sigh. It was literally my favorite read of the year until this moment, and now, though it’s still entirely wonderful, I’m not completely sure about the top spot.

*Highly* recommend for anyone looking for a gorgeous fantasy that feels timeless and fresh at the same time, and will definitely be looking for more reads by A.B. Poranek.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Thanks for reading!

Loved this one! A magical lower-YA adventure with quirky magic and lovable characters. The pace is quick, the voice is great, and I mean, who wouldn’t love a sourdough starter & gingerbread familiar? The audiobook narration was fabulous and I’d totally recommend this to anyone looking for a lower YA / upper middle grade adventure with a cozy feel (and no romance.) Fingers crossed for a sequel!

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Thanks for reading!

What I liked:
– Once again loved the complex, visceral heart-wrenching world
– Sage’s escape from her people is legit cathartic
– Beautiful writing
– I really loved the sweet relationship between Sage and her love interest
– strong found family
– deliciously righteous resistance

What I didn’t like:
– The romance is kind of insta-lovey. I actually didn’t mind it all that much, but it will definitely bug some people.
– The pacing of this one is all over the place. I feel like it started off kind of slow, and it was definitely painful to endure Sage’s culture along with her (I actually almost DNF’d at one point.) But once she escaped, I devoured this book.
– The end isn’t really an end. Obviously this is because this is a bridge into book 1 (though I don’t recommend reading this one first) but it didn’t quite leave me satisfied,

Overall though, I really enjoyed this read, totally recommend it for fans of book one, and I’m super excited to read book 2!

⭐⭐⭐⭐½

Post Review Note: So after I wrote this, I read a few reviews of books later in the series, and it sounds like the series goes in a love-triangle direction I’m not a fan of. So, I made the (actually kind of difficult) decision to stop reading this series while I still enjoyed it.

Thanks for reading!

I had a big road trip today, and I was drawn in by this book the WHOLE way. It hooked me with the complex world, epic stakes, and dark tones from the very beginning and then the misfit revolutionary vibes of the lovable cast and the slowburn budding romance had me till the very end. Note this book does have a lot of heavy, complex themes and it does not pull punches when it comes to the dark reality of their society (genocide, slavery, abuse, racism, religious extremism… I could probably go on), so it won’t be for everyone, but for me, the pacing and story-building were totally on point. I’m not going to lie, I think I enjoyed this one more than Fourth Wing (there are definitely similarities) and I’m so excited to read book 2! My only note is that I don’t think this book stands alone in any way. While there is a lot of satisfying progress, and it doesn’t end on a cliffhanger, there are still so many resolutions we’ll need from the rest of the series. Recommended for those looking for an epic fantasy with intense political world-building and dark undertones.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Thanks for reading!

This book brings ALL the found family and cozy fantasy vibes. I loved the characters and the sweet budding romance, but the tension was just a little low for me, and while the resolution was fitting it didn’t quite the satisfaction I was hoping. That said, if you’re looking for a low stakes, cozy read—this is for you!

⭐⭐⭐⭐¼

Thanks for reading!