For Writers: How to decide whether to self-publish, submit to small presses, or query agents. (2026)


Choosing which path to take can be a hard decision! (Photo by Oliver Roos on Unsplash)

So as a writing mentor, I find this question a lot, and honestly it’s highly dependent on your own personal goals and preferences. But since, I’ve done all three of these things, I thought I’d break down my thoughts on it in case it’s helpful to anyone.

My goal has always been for my books to reach as many readers who will enjoy them as possible. So I started out querying agents, because I knew that I wouldn’t be able to match the marketing and distribution of a big-five publisher by myself.

But after querying for a couple years with no dice, I decided to self-publish my first series (a YA epic fantasy, Odriel’s Heirs), and had a great experience with it! There’s a serious learning curve, but there are a *ton* of resources online, and overall, it was very doable. This was an article I wrote on how I did it back in 2020.

Self-Publishing Pros:

·         You have all the control. You choose the editor, (or you can try editing yourself), and if they propose changes you don’t want to make, you don’t have to! You choose the cover artist (or you can do it yourself.) Want a jacketed special edition or an audiobook? You can make those happen too.

·         You’re going at your own pace, whatever that is, and you don’t have to wait on querying, submission, or a publisher’s timeline. Many self-published authors take advantage of this to move super quickly and publish multiple books a year.

·         All the profits go to you!

Self-Publishing Cons

·         Self-publishing can be very time-consuming. Because not only are you responsible for writing, you’re also solely responsible for marketing, distribution, design choices, formatting, etc.

·         While the stigma against self-publishing is gradually fading, getting your books onto shelves of brick & mortar stores (especially outside your local area) can be challenging.

·         All the upfront costs are on you, and like any business, you’ll have to make good choices if you want to earn out. That said, you could self-publish on a dime, but in general, you will probably have to make some upfront investments on a cover & an editor (especially if you’re just starting out).

·         Personally, I feel like it can be harder to market confidently when you’re standing on your own. Also, your connections & opportunities are limited to those you forge on your own.

Though I had a great experience self-publishing Odriel’s Heirs, I still wanted to expand my audience. So I continued to query. I self-published my middle-grade portal fantasy, The Gatekeeper of Pericael. But then when my YA starmance, Into the Churn, also stumbled in the query trenches, I decided to give small traditional presses a try. All my experience as a self-published author continued to help me, but I also had the support of other publishing professionals. Instead of a solo sport, it now felt like I was part of a team.

Of course, all small presses are created differently. So if you’re considering one, I’d advise you to remember the following:

1. A traditional press will not charge you ANYTHING to publish your book. NOTHING. If they’re talking about fees, that is (most likely) a vanity press.

2. At a minimum, I would expect the publisher to provide: editing, a quality cover, some marketing, and distribution. If you look at the books in their catalogue, and their books have poor (or nonexistent ratings), poor covers, or exorbitant prices, I’d consider those red flags. Also, if their physical books are only available on Amazon, that would be another red flag for me.

3. They should have a submission process. If they accept all manuscripts, they are a vanity press.

4. So when vetting a publisher, make sure to check out both their social media and their website to make sure it’s presenting the image you would expect. And then if they make you an offer, I’d ask if they could connect you with some of their authors to make sure they have good experiences.

Now, if you’ve found a solid small press, these are the benefits:

Small Press Pros:

–          No cost! They take care of the editing & cover (Which will also save you time if you were thinking of doing it yourself)

–          You don’t need an agent to submit! This could potentially save you a lot of time, but many small presses have small submission windows, so make sure you follow their social media to know when and how to submit.

–          Small presses generally move quicker than bigger presses (who have more books on their schedule.) In my experience, if you sign with a small press, they usually get your book published in the following  calendar year.

–          Now you have a team of professionals behind you with publishing experience! This is a great opportunity to learn a lot, and it’s also great for confidence (in my opinion.)

Small Press Cons:

–          You now have less control. You will now have an editor and a cover artist selected by the publishing press, and you may not have final say in those elements

–          You will now share profits with the publisher (but you don’t have to share it with an agent!)

–          You are also now the small press’s schedule, whatever that is, which introduces the risk that it may go faster or slower than you like.

–          You will also have to spend time on your submission package (query & synopsis & potentially other materials) to get selected.

I contracted directly with Whimsical Publishing, and to date, have published 6 books with them (my 5-book starmance series, Into the Churn, & my paranormal mystery, Fangs, Fate, & Mondays) with another 3 projected in the next 3 years. I’ve had an awesome experience with them, and they definitely helped expand my readership.

However, as a multi-genre author, not all my books fit their brand, and I was still striving for the goal of a big-five deal, so I continued to query my manuscripts to agents. After about four-ish years of querying, my fifth manuscript got picked up by an agent, Kristen Terrette of Martin-Newens Literary, and I’ve had a great experience with it. (I probably sound like a broken record, but I am being serious. I have been *super* lucky in my small little author career so far.)

Since signing with my agent, she’s sold three of my books, which are set to release in 2027-2028. Though I haven’t scored a big-five deal yet, one of the publishers, Charlesbridge Publishing, is distributed by Penguin Random House.

Please remember that there are scammers posing as agents out there so please be careful. They should have a professional website & social media. You should be able to look up their track record on Publisher’s Marketplace. They should charge you *nothing.* (Their payment comes from a portion of your sales, usually 15%.) And, before you accept an author, they should be able to give you the contact info for some of their authors that you can ask about their experience.

Working with an Agent Pros:

– They are able to submit to bigger publishers that you cannot submit to by yourself. Which also saves you the time of having to submit on your own. And if you get a big five deal, you can expect a bigger advance, and there’s the potential for your books to be on brick and mortar bookshelves across the country

– Expert advice & guidance on the publishing industry

– They will review your contracts for you & advocate on your behalf to make sure you’re getting the best deal you can

– If you have an editorial agent, often they will help you revise & clean up your manuscript and submission package to really make sure it shines

– You also have the benefit of their added connections & opportunities

Working with an Agent Cons:

– The submission process is a long haul. Big publishers can take up to a year to respond, and when they offer you a book deal, the publishing date could be a couple years out.

– A percentage of your profits goes to your agent.

One last note is that there’s a common misconception that signing with a big press means that authors don’t have to market themselves. That is patently incorrect. The benefit of a small or big press is that they will use their resources to help you, but as the author you are always expected to market your own work. (It’s one of the reasons that your social media numbers are part of the submission package.)

Anyways, hopefully this article is helpful as you choose your path. With my goal of maximum distribution of my books, I’ve always had the dream of publishing with the big-5, which is why I’ve chosen the agented path. However, I know of other authors who are amazing at marketing themselves & extremely business savvy, who have chosen the self-publishing route to maintain control of their work and 100% of their profits.

Which is all to say, there really is no wrong answer as to which path to take. It’s a personal decision for each author to make depending on their goals and preferences.

No matter what you choose, I wish you all the luck & joy on your publishing journey!

All the paths can be satisfying, but luck is involved in each, so wishing you all the four leaf clovers!

Thanks for reading!

For Writers: Pros and Cons of Being a Multi-genre Author


So many genres!

Pros of Being a Multi-Genre Author

– Freedom! You get to stretch different skills, experiment with different writing styles, plots, settings… literally the possibilities are endless. Also those skills you hone in one genre, you can then bring to another genre, giving you more breadth and experience as a writer.

– You reach a broader swath of readers! For example, I’ve encountered readers who “read everything but sci-fi” so it’s really helpful that I can also offer fantasy, paranormal mystery, and even a children’s picture book.

– You can flex with the market. This one is a little trickier, because while I would never recommend writing for the market alone (it’s too fickle and the risk is too high that would be a lot of unsatisfying work for no payoff), I also think ignoring it completely is also unwise. For example, lately, I’ve been hearing from a lot of industry professionals that YA (which I write the most) is struggling, so I’ve largely shifted my focus to an older market.

Cons of Being a Multi-Genre Author

– Your “brand” that you market becomes nuanced rather than straight forward. For example, I usually market that my stories lean heavily into sweet, green-flag, heartfelt relationships, fast-paced writing, and found family – whether that be in contemporary romance, fantasy, sci-fi, or paranormal.

– When you shift genres, you can’t necessarily rely on your established readership to embrace a new genre. They might, but there are many readers out there who like to stick to their established favorite genres. So, when you shift, you have to hustle a little harder in your marketing ot reach your target readership. For example, I just published a cozy paranormal workplace mystery and it may not be the right cup of tea for the readers who loved the epic stakes & intense action of my sci-fi series.

– You have to be very explicit about content. Since I write picture books, middle grade, young adult, and new adult, I try to publish content guides so people know exactly what they’re getting into. For example, if someone were to love my (unpublished) kisses-only sweet YA contemporary romcom, they need to know that my upcoming fantasy horror has violence, swearing, and a closed door scene. Because the last thing I want is for a reader top pick up a book and get content that they were expecting (in the worst way.)

I mean, a colorful book stack always looks fun!

Thanks for reading!

For Writers: How do you develop fictional characters?


Characters from House of the Chosen, dark fantasy coming from Quill & Crown in Spring 2027. (Art by Chewy Gummo)

Since Chesney Infalt and I have been hosting our Plot-to-Publishing crash course in the local area, I’ve gotten this question multiple times: How do I develop characters? And this is kind of an interesting question, because I feel like every author I’ve talked to has a different way of going about this.

For example, I know for Chesney and several others, she comes up with the characters before she comes up with the plot. Though in the last five years or so, I focused from more of a plot-centered to focus to a character-centered focus, for me, the plot still comes first every time.

First it comes to me as a concept or a question, like: What if Cinderella was actually secretly assigned to protect the prince from a hit at midnight? (Codename: CNDRLA) Then after letting it percolate in my daydreams for an indeterminate amount of time, I’m then ready to write my Save-the-Cat plot beats, and it’s usually at this point that I start really thinking about the main characters in a hazy big-picture sort of way.

This is where I come up wtih a name, a description, and the problem they’re facing. Honestly, it’s usually like two lines, but the name means a *lot* to me. I feel like the name can create such a powerful conception for a character, so I do put a lot of thought into it. I’m less concerned with the meaning of the name, and more of the vibe & picture it conjures in my mind. Once I get that mental image right, it encapsulates so much of their pesonality (for me) in a way that’s hard to put into words. Sometimes, I’ll even sketch them out or make a little moodboard for them to make it more concrete.

From there, I write an outline with a little blurb for each chapter. Then I write what I sometimes call a “zero draft” which is very skeletal, unreadable version of the first draft which is usually like 10-20k short of the final wordcount. And *that* is when I actually meet the characters. For me, writing that zero draft is the real introduction to the characters. It’s where I start to hear their voices, the depth of their background, and their quirks.

So even though, I consider myself a plotter, when it comes to characters, that is where I think I could be described as more of a discovery writer. Often in that first draft, the characters are even a little inconsistent as I poke and prod them to see where they really fit and who they really are.

But by the time I finish that zero draft, I know them. It’s then that I can more formally write out their details, what they want, and what they need. And often, it’s only then that I’ll commission character art, now that they seem real in my mind.

So, that’s me. I start with a plot and a couple character lines and discover the characters along the way. And to be honest, that’s how I think of the reading experience as well. Going into a book, I may have an idea of the plot, but it’s the characters I’m really getting to know and learning to love or hate on the journey.

I know that’s probably an unsatisfying answer to those who want to plot out everything before they jump into a draft, but no matter how much you plan, sometimes the stories and the characters take unexpected turns. But that’s half the fun of it, so don’t be afraid to take the leap and enjoy the ride!

The Into the Churn crew wishes you luck! (Art by @valkyriefreia)

Thanks for reading!

What does a writing process look like?


I recently had someone ask how I tackle revisions and realized the writing process I posted years ago has evolved as I’ve grown more efficient. Honestly when you’re writing the first one or two books, I think one of things you’re also doing is defining your writing process. The process is something that improves over time, and I try to look it over every now and again to see if it needs any tweaking. While everyone’s will look different, if you’re starting from a blank page and looking for a starting point, here’s how mine goes.

(I’ve delineated the thought from the writing time that these steps takes because I’m a firm believer that writing is 90% thought and 10% writing it down, but it’s very difficult to measure the amount of time you think about something. And most people seem to hyper-fixate on the amount of writing time anyway. )

1.      Plot Seed: Plot idea strikes from the aether, and I write it down My latest one came from a microfiction piece I wrote for the NYC midnight writing challenge. The one before that was just a random hypothetically that popped into my head. Just make sure you write it down! The writing portion of this process takes about 30 seconds.

2.      Outline: The idea usually percolates in the brain space for a few days before I decide that I absolutely need to write it and type up the 1-page Save the Cat Outline. The writing portion of this takes about 30 minutes.

3.      Detailed Outline / Zero Draft: I write up a chapter-by-chapter outline. Sometimes this is more detailed than others. Sometimes it’s a summary of what happens in each chapter, and sometimes it reads like the screenplay (dialogue-only) version of the chapter outline which I sometimes refer to as a zero draft. The writing time varies widely as this chapter outline/zero draft can be anywhere from like 3,000-20,000 words, which is like 3-20 hours.

If I put more time here, the next step will be quicker. If I skimp on this part, the next step takes longer. Mostly, it depends on what other projects I have going on at the time as to how much time I put into this, and how fully I’ve thought about it. You could also break this into two steps, but I’m not sure if I’ve ever done it that way. In my most recent first drafts, I’ve just done a short chapter outline which probably took me about 3 hours.

4.     First Draft: In this draft I’m just telling the story to myself. Getting the bare bones of it down on paper and maintaining momentum. I cannot understate this enough – this sucker is literally unreadable by anyone else. It will have too many inconsistencies for the story to make sense, the setting details will be minimal, and I show it to no one. So, it will usually fall about 10-15k words short of whatever the final word count will be. That said it usually takes me about 1 hour per 1000 words, and I write shorter novels, so 70,000 is usually pretty normal for me. Let’s say 70 hours. If I budget 2000 words/day, which is doable for me, that’s 35 days of writing.

5.      First Revision: This is where I make it readable for my first reader, which, these days, is one of my long-term critique partners (who are also authors). It’s honestly pretty difficult for me to gage how long this takes. I think it takes about 2-3 weeks, which at 2 hours/day, is an average of 35 hours, which sounds about right. This is definitely the hardest revision.

6.      Second Revision: After I get it back from that first reader, I revise again. This one usually goes a lot faster, since I have specific advice from another author friend, and takes me about a week, so we’ll say about 14 hours. After that, it goes out to 2-3 first-round Beta Readers. These are trusted beta readers I’ve used multiple times, and who have read many of my stories. Most of them are authors, but I have one professional beta reader I’ve been using for a long time.

7.      Sanity-Check Revision: Finally, it goes out to second-round Beta Readers, who are 2-3 readers (not writers.) This is really just a sanity check to make sure the story works, but also usually results in some very small tweaks. Maybe like 4 hours.

8.      Industry Professional Revision: This is also where I send it to my Developmental Editor at Whimsical or my agent. They will both send me edits which can take varying amounts of time. I think we usually do at least two rounds which take about 1-2 weeks each. So probably about 24 hours.

9.      Post-Submission Revision: So far, I’ve only done this once, but if the book gets picked up by a publisher from submission, there will be another editor-led round of revision. I’m sure the amount of time this takes varies widely depending on the editor, but I’d estimate about 24 hours again.

10. Line Edits and Proofing: These are super quick they come as recommendations from the copyeditor and proofreader and are generally very straight forward. I’d say 2 hours each for a total of 4 hours.

So there it is: 178 hours, 30 min, and 30 seconds of my authorly writing time to get a book ready to publish. Since I do about 2 hours of writing a day, that’s about 90 days of work spread out across varying lengths of time depending on the speed of publishing and how many projects I’m working.

Please keep in mind that this does not include the publisher’s, agent, editor, critique partner, and beta reader time that also goes into. And it doesn’t include thinking time either. Which is just to say, it takes a lot of time for myself (and the people around me) to get a book ready for publication.

It’s funny, when I started this post, I thought it would show how much my process has been streamlined and simplified, but honestly looking at it, it reads more complicated than it feels. But that’s probably just because at this point, 20+ books in, I’m just very comfortable with it.

When that writer asked me about tips for revision, my biggest advice was to use CPs and Beta Readers to help you find where and how to revise because their objective eyes will save you tons of time. Also, I think when you’re first starting out, it’s easy to want to revise a book forever with the idea that it’ll never be good enough. But just remember, every revision will bring diminishing returns, and any growth you experience in writing this book, you will bring to the next book as well.

So as you write, give thought to your process, so that you know both when to sit down and begin, when you need another pair of eyes, and when it’s time to send that book baby out in the world and hope it flies!

Happy Writing!

Thanks for reading!

How to Find Confidence as an Author Amid Failure and Rejection


So, if you’ve been following my end-of-the-year writing wrap-up posts, I think we can all agree that I ended on a little bit of a downer at the end of 2025. Between the looming creative apocalypse that is genAI and my own personal odyssey of submission, I will readily admit that I came into 2026 floundering and a little hopeless about the prospects of my writing career.

So, I set my focus for 2026 to make myself slow down, search for balance, and re-center on my joy of the craft. My Fantasy Horror manuscript went on sub in February, and then I took to writing craft books. I was lucky enough to stumble upon Ray Bradbury’s Zen in the Art of Writing, and it was honestly the perfect book that I needed to shove me out of my mental spiral.

Somewhere along the way, I’d gotten caught up in the idea of “author career success” defining the worth of my words. I’m sure if you’re reading this, that probably makes sense to you as well. But when my mind was slanted in that direction, all I could think of was the need for a manuscript to succeed on submission. But when that thought consumed me, every day without a new book deal felt like a failure. So to try to escape that negative mindset, I tried to shift my thinking to assume that all my submission would be failures. That way, I figured if I was perpetually prepared for the worst, then I could be inured against rejection.

Honestly, it was a step forward, but it was still kind of a hopeless mentality. It was only when Zen in the Art of Writing really reminded me that success, big or small, isn’t the point at all. But rather the joy and honesty of it. The point is to mine the originality of our own experience to more fully perceive the world around us.

And you might look at that, and think, “well, obviously, Hayley.” But knowing a thing and your bones knowing a thing are two different beasts entirely. Only when I’d accepted the inherent worth of my own words and the exercise of writing—two things that no rejection could ever steal from me—was I able to relax again. I felt free to write what I *needed* to write. To take my time. To soak it in. To enjoy creation and the truths it reveals to myself. To, as Ray Bradbury put it, get “busy loving and hating.”

Once solidly in this new headspace, I then felt weirdly confident. Because I knew, naturally, that I’ve survived hundreds of rejections, and that any matter of hundreds more would not blow my ship over. That I didn’t have to bow to the pressures of industry to burn my little free time to attempt to be a prolific social media marketer first. Because I’d re-found the “why” of my writing. And if we want to get into a Nietzsche quote here, “He who has a why to live for can bear almost any how,”—the  same goes for writing.

Some come what may of our ‘how’—rejections, genAI slop, traditional publishing follower-requirements—I have my ‘why.’ And if you’re a creative struggling with these same realities, I hope you’re able to take a moment to re-center yourself and your work as well. Highly recommend.

Don’t let the genAI slop win.

Thanks for reading!

Book Review – Zen in the Art of Writing


I’ve read quite a few writing craft books at this point, and I’ll be honest, quite a few of them are misses for me, but I really enjoyed this one. I’ve definitely been feeling a little lost in my author life, and this was *exactly* the book I needed. Bradbury’s writing is straight up mesmerizing, the descriptions of his journey, writing process, inspirations, and advice were fascinating, and in general, I think he gets straight at the heart of writing. I absolutely recommend it, but know going in, this is less concrete advice about how to write, and more about finding the balance amidst industry pressures and motivations – about centering on the art in our writing and ourselves.

A Favorite Quote: “The faster you blurt, the more swiftly you write, the more honest you are. In hesitation is thought. In delay comes the effort for a style, instead of leaping upon truth which is the only style worth deadfalling or tiger-trapping.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Thanks, Ray, I needed this one.

Thanks for reading!

Book Review – Creating Characters: The Complete Guide to Populating Your Fiction


Since this one has articles from various authors on the same topics, there’s a lot of repetition in this one. I don’t remember what “recommended writing craft books” list I found this on, but it wasn’t my favorite.

Favorite Quote: “The further you stray from reader expectation, the more obligated you are to explain how you got there.”

Still searching for the writing craft book I need in my life. I know it’s out there!

Thanks for reading!

Book Review – Dialogue by Robert McKee


So I read Story by McKee and couldn’t really get into it, and unfortunately, I felt the same way about this one. A lot of these elements feel repetitive, and are illustrated through in-depth analysis of selected screenplays. Personally, I felt like it read like a super dry textbook without as many insightful nuggets as I would’ve hoped for. In general, the way the information is presented just didn’t really hit for me, but it could work for you!

Favorite Quote: “The more emotional people become, the shorter the words and sentences they use; the more rational people become, the longer the words and sentences they use.”

Honestly, finding a compelling writing craft book is tough. There are a few that I’ve loved… but I’ve tried quite a few at this point. Still, I’m always looking for ways to improve my writing, so I’ll keep at it!

Thanks for reading!

WriteHive Mentorship Program 2026!

I’m so excited to announce I’ll be returning to the WriteHive Mentorship Program for my second year as a mentor. I had a great experience as a mentee in 2023, and again as a mentor in 2024, so I highly recommend this program to anyone looking for some help in whipping their manuscript into shape! I’ve included my mentor wishlist, profile and expectations below, but I highly recommend you check out all the mentor profiles here.

While you don’t submit to a specific mentor, I found it super helpful last year when applicants listed a few mentors they thought would be a good fit in their query/submission letters.

Also, if you’re curious as to what I’m looking for in submissions, you can find my breakdown of the submissions from last year here.

Last year, I went with Erin Scheuer‘s sweet new adult romantic comedy with YA crossover appeal which had huge K-drama vibes that I absolutely adored. But honestly this year, I’m pretty open when it comes to target audience and genre. There will be a Mentor AMA on WriteHive’s Discord & Bluesky next week if you have more questions, but if you’re on the fence about submitting, I hope you decide to take the leap!

Submissions will be open from Nov 14-16 and I can’t wait to see what comes in. If you’re submitting, good luck, and I’m excited to read your pitch!

Cheers friends and good luck!

For Writers: Why was my manuscript rejected?

So I became a WriteHive mentor because I wanted to pay forward all the wisdom and experience the writing community had gifted me over the years. And since I’ve done quite a lot of beta reading, critique swaps with partners, and also worked with quite a few editors over the years, I felt pretty comfortable that I’d be able to help someone improve their manuscript.

But what I totally wasn’t expecting was everything I learned during the manuscript selection process. I hadn’t considered that this was the first time I was on the other side of an acceptance/rejection decision. And what it brought it really home for me was that authors had actually requested me as a mentor in their queries!🤯I was so completely flattered and blown away.

In this article, I’m going to break down how I narrowed the submissions to select my mentee, the materials I looked at, and the questions I asked myself along the way. I found this a very enlightening process and thought it might be helpful for others going through the querying or submission trenches. However, please keep in mind, everyone has their own methods for selecting manuscripts for both representation, mentoring, and publication. This was simply the process and realizations I had during mine.

Here’s a quick breakdown of how many submissions came in for 17 mentors:

140 submissions (a 52% increase over 2024 – yay!)

Age demographic submission breakdown:

  • MG: 12 (8.6%)
  • YA: 39 (27.9%)
  • NA: 15 (10.7%)
  • Adult: 74 (52.8%)

Publishing path submission breakdown:

  • Unsure about Publishing Path: 21 (15%)
  • Self Publishing: 14 (10%)
  • Indie / Small Press: 20 (14.3%)
  • Traditional: 85 (60.7%)

And genre breakdown:

  • Fantasy: 51 (36.4%)
  • Romance: 23 (16.4%)
  • Romantasy: 23 (16.4%)
  • Contemporary/Literary/Nonfiction: 17 (12.2%)
  • Horror/Suspense/Mystery: 16 (11.4%)
  • Sci-Fi: 10 (7.2%)

Each submission included their bio, the state of their manuscript (where was it in the writing process), pitch, their query letter, a synopsis, and their full manuscript. But how to narrow it down? I really wanted to make sure I picked the mentee who I could help most. A manuscript I could really fall in love with, but also one that I could help in a concrete way.

The first cut

So, even though I had outlined my general preferences in my MSWL (manuscript wishlist), I read the pitch, query, and first page of all 140 submissions, with one question in mind:

Does the premise grab me?

Based on that question alone (which, by the way, had *nothing* to do with the talent of the author or the quality of writing and everything to do with personal preference), I was able to cut my list down from 140 to 26.

That, in itself, blew me away. After all, I’ve received many rejections, and of course, every time, I assumed it was because I wasn’t a good enough author. My writing wasn’t good enough. The story wasn’t good enough.

But here I was, cutting 81% of the submissions with no regard to quality at all. Honestly, I probably could’ve done it based on the pitch alone.

Interesting.

So with that cut, my list was down to:
3/12 Middle Grade: 25%
9/39 Young Adult: 23%
2/15 New Adult: 13%
12/74 Adult: 16%
Total Longlist: 26/140

The Second cut

For there, I reviewed the bio, the state of the manuscript, their synopsis, and their query again. From these materials, the mentees included information on if they’d started querying it, which paths – traditional, small press, or self-publishing – they’d consider pursuing, and what they were looking for in a mentorship.

On my second cut, I was asking myself: Is this a mentee I can help? Am I the type of mentor they’re looking for?

Once again, I was not considering the quality of the story or writing at all. I was simply trying to ascertain at this point if we could be a good match based on my strengths and the kind of mentor they were looking for.

In the second cut I went from a longlist of 26 to a longlist of 12.

2/12 MG: 17%
3/39 YA: 8%
1/15 NA: 7%
6/74 Adult: 8%
Total Trimmed Longlist: 12

So at this point, I had cut 91% of the submission without considering quality of writing or story.

The third cut

The third is where I finally read the entirety of the first chapter and then asked myself: Am I drawn to keep reading? This is the first question I’d asked that could have been attributed to writing quality.

The third cut took me from a longlist of 12 to a short list of 7: 2 Young Adult Manuscripts and 5 Adult Manuscripts. From there, I read further into the manuscripts, and once again, this time, looking for the manuscript that I thought would be most suited to my tastes. In the end, I chose the story I had extremely concrete recommendations for, one which was very much suited to my personal taste, and had an author who was searching for knowledge areas I had. And just as an aside, only one of my top 3 choices showed up on another mentor’s top 3. For the most part, all of our top 3 choices were radically different.

So what’s the point?

When it came to publishing, I’d often heard the phrase “right eyes, right time.” Meaning essentially, that there are tons of quality stories out there, but you need to find the right agent/editor that’s the best fit to champion yours at the right time in the market. Which… comes down to a lot of factors outside of your control.

But once again, every time I faced a rejection, it was so easy to take it as a sign that I wasn’t good enough to be an author. Or the story wasn’t good enough to be published. But the truth is, writing, as an artform, is so personal. No one book is for everyone – and that fact is as true before publishing as after it.

So, if you submitted to the WriteHive mentorship, please don’t be discouraged in any way if you weren’t selected as a mentee. It really has no reflection on your ability as a writer or a storyteller, but rather simply, if your story was a good match for the mentors reading submissions this year.

And as I continue to trudge on in the submission trenches, I’m trying to keep the very same lesson in mind. That my stories need to find the right eyes at the right time. Whether that’s next week or next year or in three years really isn’t up to me. All I can do is be patient and keep writing the best stories that I can.

Hopefully, if you’re in the query or submission trenches, this has been helpful in some way and can also help you to find the mindset and perseverence you need on your writing journey.

Rejections are tough. There’s no two ways about it. Just remember to take care of yourself, take lots of breaks, and keep on keeping on.
Begin. Grow. Persevere.

Thanks for reading!